Case 1
One lump
Death of a Jam Judge
The Upper Mallowby summer fête had survived rain, wasps and the year the donkey ate the raffle prizes, but it had never before lost a judge. Mr Septimus Crowe had come over from Cheltenham to judge the preserves. By half past two he had called the winning damson jam “brave”. By half past three he was lying behind the bunting, felled by a single blow from a toffee hammer.
PC Nettle soon found that three villagers had each been at a different stall, each holding something they should not have had. Mrs Quayle bought a raffle ticket, sat down on a hay bale and asked him to read out his notebook. Slowly, please.
Who struck Mr Crowe with the toffee hammer, and where was everyone?
Constable Nettle’s notebook
- 1.Mrs Lockyer had neither the toffee hammer nor the cake slice. She has never trusted toffee.
- 2.The toffee hammer was not at the coconut shy.
- 3.Miss Gosling, who runs the post office and therefore knows everything, had neither the croquet mallet nor the toffee hammer.
- 4.Neither Mrs Lockyer nor Miss Gosling was at the tombola.
- 5.The cake slice was either at the coconut shy or at the tombola.
| Jam tent | Tombola | Coconut shy | Croquet mallet | Toffee hammer | Cake slice | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mrs Lockyer | ||||||
| The Major | ||||||
| Miss Gosling | ||||||
| Croquet mallet | ||||||
| Toffee hammer | ||||||
| Cake slice |
Tap a square once for a cross, twice for a dot, three times to clear it.
Prefer paper? The printable version has the rules, the case and the full solution, on three pages.
Download the case (PDF, 110 KB)



